Whitewash Croydon tram inquest verdict raises more questions than answers | Croydon Conservatives Skip to main content
Logo icon
Croydon
Conservatives

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • Campaigns
  • MPs & GLA
  • Your Local Team
  • Get involved
  • About us
  • Donate
Logo icon
Croydon
Conservatives

Whitewash Croydon tram inquest verdict raises more questions than answers

  • Tweet
Thursday, 22 July, 2021
  • Local News
Sandilands tram tragedy

Neil Garratt, London Assembly Member for Croydon and Sutton, reacts to today's result of the Sandilands tram inquest.

Today the inquest into the Sandilands tram crash concluded with the jury returning a disappointing verdict of accidental death. I share the anger that seven people’s deaths are put down as simply an accident, when we have seen both the safety problems that the investigation brought to light, and the attempts to hide from scrutiny.

I am deeply concerned that no one from either Transport for London (TfL) or Tram Operations Ltd (TOL) was called to give evidence at the inquest, because the Coroner declined to invite them.

Had they been called, they might have explained why there were no speed limit signs at the end of the long straight track leading to the tight bend where the crash occurred. This corner had a history of speeding incidents: drivers had used the emergency brake there at least nine previous times. It later emerged that less than two weeks before the fatal crash, another tram had come within 2mph of tipping over on this corner.

When the driver suffering a “microsleep” is believed to have caused the crash, TfL or TOL might have explained why three-quarters of tram drivers thought the fatigue management system for drivers was inadequate. Two years before the crash, there was both a confidential whistleblower report about shift patterns causing tiredness, and an independent audit of TOL which found seven weaknesses. One weakness was fatigue management. This information wasn’t included in the original crash investigation because TfL didn’t provide it, it only came to light years later.

The Coroner ought to have asked TfL and TOL about these events, and also why drivers’ fear of repercussions made them wary of reporting such problems to management. Collectively, both these safety problems and the culture of hiding them led the former TfL Board Member to describe TfL as “institutionally unsafe”. It’s hard to disagree.

The inquest jury considered the facts presented to them for more than nine days, and I thank them for their commitment. But without hearing a single word of evidence from either TfL or TOL, they were given an impossible task.

Many of us had high hopes that after years of official obstruction, the inquest would finally get to the bottom of what happened and give families and loved ones of the crash victims some closure. I am afraid that it leaves more questions than answers, in particular why the inquest did not call TfL or TOL to answer for their actions. Those failings are a concern not just for the Sandilands victims and families, but across London’s public transport system.

The only way that the families of those departed, and the community torn apart from this tragedy, can get closure is if the process is beyond reproach. Sadly that did not happen here, and so the pursuit of justice continues. I will do all I can to support the families affected to reach the peace that they need.

This was first published by CityAM on 22nd July 2021.

You may also be interested in

Neil Garratt Headshot

Neil Garratt

Croydon & Sutton GLA Member

Neil is Croydon & Sutton's GLA Member. He is also a Conservative Councillor for Belmont.

Croydon & Sutton (London Assembly)

The Croydon & Sutton GLA seat comprises of the entirety of the London Borough of Croydon and the London Borough of Sutton. The seat has been Conservative-held since it's creation in 2000. Our assembly member since the 2021 election is Neil Garratt.

Labour's Financial Mistakes

REVEALED: The true scale of Croydon Labour’s toxic financial mismanagement

Tuesday, 22 November, 2022

Croydon Labour’s financial mismanagement has required the Council to issue a new Section 114 notice.
Official reports detail “mistakes” made in the previous Administration’s budgets – which Labour claimed were “balanced” – worth tens of millions of pounds.

Show only

  • Articles
  • Assembly News
  • Holyrood News
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Opinions
  • Reports
  • Speeches
  • Westminster News

Join or Renew

Help us take action on local issues and build a better Britain.

accepted-payment-cards

Croydon Conservatives

Footer

  • About RSS
  • Accessibility
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • About us
  • Donate
  • Get involved
ConservativesPromoted by Ian Parker on behalf of Croydon Conservative Federation, both at 36 Brighton Road, Purley, CR8 2LG
Copyright 2023 Croydon Conservatives . All rights reserved.
Powered by Bluetree