Skip to main content
Site logo
Site logo
Croydon
Conservatives

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • Campaigns
  • MPs & GLA
  • Your Councillors
  • Get involved
  • About us
  • Croydon Council - Labour’s Bankruptcy
  • Need Support?

We warned Labour: poor audit processes

  • Tweet
Tuesday, 10 November, 2020
Poor audit processes

The Council’s General Purpose & Audit Committee, known as GPAC, plays the same role as the audit committee in a large company, providing a body to review adherence to internal processes and all financial processes. The Council’s internal audit function and the external auditors, Grant Thornton who recently released a devastating ‘Report in the Public Interest’ detailing the Council’s flawed financial management, report to GPAC.

Therefore, it should be a serious, technical and, crucially, independent committee. However, until September this year, every time the committee met the Labour Cabinet Member for Finance and Resources was sat at the front of the room; making his presence felt at a committee of which he was deliberately not a member.

Cllr. Hall was there to oversee the presentations which Council Officers and external auditors gave. He was there to jump in first to respond to any questions, even if they were addressed to officers, setting the tone for how this failing Labour Council expected the question to be answered. He was there to keep the Labour members of the committee from asking anything embarrassing. He shockingly reviewed the reports which were presented to the Committee before we received them.

In short, Councillor Hall’s presence completely removed the teeth from a Committee which is supposed to be one of the most important in the Council. A rosy picture of the Council’s finance and governance was presented, and any difficult questions were twisted politically by Councillor Hall. Any issue could only be the fault of the Government which was not providing enough money for Councillor Hall to spend.

The rosy picture was shattered by Grant Thornton’s report, which is only the 5th such report to be issued anywhere in the country in the last four years (and the first in London), such is the true state of the Council’s financial mis-management and governance. The report referenced GPAC, and was broadly critical of how the committee had held the Council leadership to account, but noted that at two meetings this month “a more robust approach is being taken to matters of concern raised to the General Purposes and Audit Committee.” It is no coincidence that Councillor Hall was not in attendance at either meeting.

Without Councillor Hall’s foreboding presence at GPAC meetings, Labour Councillors were suddenly free to question officers as directly and openly as Conservative Councillors, and officers were free to answer questions openly as well. I asked the Council’s Head of Internal Audit whether, as far as performance against Internal Audit reviews goes, the Council’s performance had got worse every year for 5 years and he responded, simply, truthfully and succinctly, “Yes”. It is difficult to imagine him giving such a clear answer had he been watched over by the then Cabinet Member for Finance.

Unfortunately, Labour’s approach to GPAC over the last 6 years is reflective of its approach to the whole of the Council. It did not want scrutiny, and it certainly didn’t want to listen to suggestions that its approach might be wrong. So, it took every effort to hide information which might be embarrassing, even from statutory bodies such as GPAC. The culture of secrecy led to poor governance, and a number of independent reports have now confirmed that this poor governance has led to the desperate state that the Council’s finances are now in. 

Councillor Hall and Councillor Newman may now have resigned, but 7 of the Cabinet’s 10 members, including the new leader, served alongside them. They were part of that culture of secrecy, and part of that culture of failure. 

Croydon deserves better.

  • Local News

You may also be interested in

Stuart Millson

Stuart Millson

Selsdon Vale & Forestdale
Opposition General Purpose and Audit Committee Lead

Stuart Millson has lived in South Croydon since 2015. He also set up his business, comparison site Broker Compare, in the town. Stuart believes that the next 4 years are critical to the economic development of Croydon.

Shadow Cabinet

As the opposition on Croydon Council, the Conservatives form a Shadow Cabinet to scrutinise and challenge the Labour Councillors. Please find more information about our current Shadow Cabinet here.

We Warned Labour

We Warned Labour

Our failing Labour Council has driven Croydon to the brink of bankruptcy due to their terrible choices.

£15,000 of debt every hour since 2014. That's over £1.5 billion debt making Croydon one of the worst run Council's in the country.

Vulnerable children at risk

Impact of Labour's cuts to Children's Services  

Sunday, 7 March, 2021

This has been such a dark year for so many people due to Covid-19.  

Children and young people have been profoundly affected in many ways.  

Show only

  • Articles
  • European News
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Opinions
  • Reports
  • Speeches
  • Westminster News

Join or Renew

Help us take action on local issues and build a better Britain.

accepted-payment-cards

Croydon Conservative Federation

Footer

  • About RSS
  • Accessibility
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • About us
  • Get involved
Site logoPromoted by Ian Parker on behalf of Croydon Conservative Federation both at 36 Brighton Road, Purley, CR8 2LG
Copyright 2021 Croydon Conservative Federation. All rights reserved.
Powered by Bluetree